Booster Vaccine Uptake and Hesitancy in Canada from February to October 2022

Download this article (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Download the full issue (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Download the French edition (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Read this article in French

Introduction and background

There is now a mountain of evidence to suggest that the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted certain groups and communities in Canada more than others. Canadians who were in precarious economic situations prior to the outbreak are now facing even more dire circumstances. Indigenous Peoples, visible minorities and newcomers to Canada tend to be overrepresented among those in vulnerable social and economic conditions (Statistics Canada, 2022).

Visible minorities are at an increased risk of infection and mortality from COVID-19 (Subedi et al. 2020). One of the contributing factors to increased risk is working in sectors where there is a greater risk of exposure to COVID-19, such as the overrepresentation of Black and Filipino employees in the health care and social assistance industry (Turcotte and Savage, 2020). Immigrants are also disproportionately represented in sectors with greater exposure to COVID-19—front-line and essential service workers, including long-term care, where the majority of deaths have occurred (Statistics Canada, 2020).

An Ontario study found that rates of COVID-19 infection were three times higher in neighbourhoods with higher concentrations of visible minorities (Public Health Ontario, 2020). The same study found hospitalization rates to be four times higher and deaths were twice as high. Visible minority groups were also more likely to experience job loss or reduced work hours compared to Whites during the pandemic, especially Filipinos and West Asians (Statistics Canada, 2020).

Another contributing factor to the COVID-19 experiences of Indigenous Peoples, visible minorities and newcomers is vaccine hesitancy. Many Indigenous people have expressed substantial hesitancy and even opposition to vaccination for COVID-19 (Mosby and Swidrovich, 2021). The Canadian Community Health Survey (2020) revealed that all three of these groups were more reluctant to receive the COVID-19 vaccine (Statistics Canada 2021).

With support from Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR), the Association for Canadian Studies (ACS) and University of Manitoba conducted a cross-national comparison of Canada, United States and Mexico to understand and answer the following research question: To what extent has the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated socioeconomic inequalities faced by Indigenous Peoples, racialized persons and immigrants? And as a follow up question: How has vaccine (and booster) hesitancy contributed to these social and economic disparities?

Five large-scale population-based surveys were conducted between October 2020 (Wave 1) and October 2022 (Wave 5) with over 40,000 respondents in Canada, United States and Mexico. The surveys were administered by Leger Marketing using a Computer-Assisted Web Interface (CAWI) approach. The focus of this study is on Wave 4 and 5 data for Canada.

Various themes were explored in each survey wave, which were contingent upon time-relevant issues surrounding the pandemic. Some of the major themes focused on financial impacts of the pandemic, fear of catching COVID-19, vaccine uptake and hesitancy, mental and physical health, and trust in institutions. This current study focuses on vaccine uptake and hesitancy in Canada—topics which were at the forefront of discussions around COVID-19 during 2022 and coincided with the final two survey waves. (See Table 1)

DemographicsWave 4Wave 5
Sample size29393031
Sex
Male48.3%48.5%
Female51.7%51.5%
Age
Between 18 and 2410.7%10.1%
Between 25 and 3416.6%16.5%
Between 35 and 4416.0%16.5%
Between 45 and 5418.3%15.7%
Between 55 and 6417.3%17.5%
65 and older21.1%23.6%
Ethnicity
White74.1%74.1%
Indigenous5.0%5.0%
Black3.6%3.6%
Asian12.0%12.1%
Other5.4%5.3%
Immigrant Status
Non-immigrant78.1%77.8%
Immigrant21.6%21.9%
Province
British Columbia13.5%13.9%
Alberta11.2%11.1%
Prairies6.5%6.4%
Ontario38.4%38.7%
Quebec23.5%23.1%
Maritimes6.9%6.7%
Table 1. Demographic information of the Canadian sample for Wave 4 (February-March 2022) and Wave 5 (October 2022).

Vaccine uptake—quantitative analysis

Figure 1 below portrays the rate of vaccination among Canadians surveyed in February-March 2022 (Wave 4) and October 2022 (Wave 5). While the overall rate of vaccination (at least one dose) did not change much across the survey waves (increased from 88% to 90%), there was a slight uptick in the proportion of Canadians who received their third, fourth and fifth doses (boosters), up from 61% in Wave 3 to 67% in Wave 4 (42% with 3 doses, 24% with 4 doses and 1% with five doses). Much of this increase however can be accounted for by the wider availability of booster shots in October 2022 compared to the spring of 2022. (See Figure 1)

Stacked bar chart with a vertical axis from 0% to 100% in steps of 20% and two bars: Wave 4 (Feb-Mar 2022) and Wave 5 (October 2022). The legend lists six categories: 0 doses (unvaccinated), 1 dose, 2 doses, 3 doses, 4 doses and 5 doses or more. Wave 4, from the bottom: 0 doses 11.8%, 1 dose 1.1%, 2 doses 25.9%, 3 doses 61.2%, with a 0.0% label at the top of the bar. Wave 5, from the bottom: 0 doses 9.7%, 1 dose 1.1%, 2 doses 21.9%, 3 doses 42.4%, 4 doses 23.8%, and 1.0% labelled at the top of the bar.

See page 35 of the PDF (opens in a new tab)

Figure 1. Vaccine uptake across survey waves 4 and 5.

Vaccine intentions by key sociodemographics

In the spring of 2022 (Wave 4), approximately half of Canadians (50.4%) who had received the initial two doses of a COVID-19 vaccine intended to get a third booster dose. However, intentions to get vaccinated for a third time were dependent on whether or not boosters were compulsory, at least for half of those who reported intentions to get vaccinated (See Table 2a).

Males were somewhat more likely to get a third booster vaccine (54% total ‘Yes’ responses) than females (47%), and a Pearson’s Chi-Square test found these differences to be statistically significant (X² = 8.58, p <.05). There were also observable differences across age groups (X² = 37.63, p <.001) and ethnic groups (X² = 23.56, p <.05). It appears that younger and older Canadians were the most likely to get a third vaccine compared to the middle-age groups in the spring of 2022. For instance, nearly two-thirds of Canadian youth aged 18 to 24 (65%) and Canadians aged 65 and over (63%) intended to get a third vaccine compared to less than half of Canadians in all other age groups (46% on average). Asian Canadians had the highest booster vaccine intentions (68% ‘yes’ responses) while Black Canadians were the most hesitant (39% ‘yes’ responses). Immigrants also had slightly higher intentions than non-immigrants to get vaccinated, but these differences were not statistically significant (See Table 2a).

There were also large differences in booster vaccine intentions across provinces or regions of Canada (X² = 76.47, p <.001), income (X² = 40.44, p <.001), educational attainment levels (X² = 39.12, p <.001), and across the political spectrum (X² = 58.90, p <.001). The two Canadian coasts had the highest rates of vaccine intentions (61% ‘yes’ responses in BC and 67% in the Maritimes), however BC respondents were much more definitive in their intentions to get1 vaccinated (46% reporting ‘Yes’ and 15% reporting ‘Yes, but only if required’) compared to East Coast respondents (19% reporting ‘Yes’ and ‘49% reporting ‘Yes, but only if required’). The picture was less clear in terms of income, however, lower and upper-income Canadians appeared to be more definitive in their booster intentions, with over 30 percent in each group responding ‘Yes’ unconditionally. Among educational groups, university graduates reported the highest intentions to get boosters (57% responding ‘Yes’ or ‘Yes, but only if required’) while those who situate themselves to the left of the political spectrum were also more likely to get a third booster compared to those Canadians on the political right (see Table 2b).

Wave 4 (Feb - March 2022)Do you intend to get a third booster vaccine?
YesNoYes, but only if requiredI don’t know
Total25.9%37.1%24.5%12.5%
Sex
Male27.9%37.0%25.9%9.2%
Female24.4%37.5%22.2%15.9%
Age
Between 18 and 2432.0%23.1%32.7%12.2%
Between 25 and 3426.8%41.1%21.5%10.5%
Between 35 and 4428.6%35.3%24.8%11.3%
Between 45 and 5417.0%43.7%22.2%17.0%
Between 55 and 6417.0%48.9%22.3%11.7%
65 and older41.9%25.6%20.9%11.6%
Ethnicity
White23.9%40.0%23.9%12.1%
Indigenous23.7%34.2%23.7%18.4%
Black20.5%38.6%18.2%22.7%
Asian37.4%24.3%30.8%7.5%
Other26.7%41.7%23.3%8.3%
Immigrant Status
Non-immigrant31.0%33.5%25.4%10.2%
Immigrant24.4%38.5%24.2%12.9%
Table 2a. Canadians’ intentions to get a third vaccine booster (Wave 4 data).
Wave 4 (Feb - March 2022)Do you intend to get a third booster vaccine?
YesNoYes, but only if requiredI don’t know
Total25.9%37.1%24.5%12.5%
Province
British Columbia45.9%19.4%15.3%19.4%
Alberta22.4%50.9%21.6%5.2%
Prairies20.0%38.0%14.0%28.0%
Ontario24.2%34.3%27.8%13.7%
Quebec23.3%43.8%23.3%9.7%
Maritimes18.6%25.6%48.8%7.0%
Education
High school or less27.0%29.0%26.2%17.7%
Postsecondary schooling21.2%45.0%22.2%11.6%
University bachelor degree or higher31.2%36.6%26.2%5.9%
Income
$19,999 or less31.3%37.3%18.1%13.3%
Between $20,000 and $39,99913.3%40.8%35.8%10.0%
Between $40,000 and $59,99925.5%33.3%27.5%13.7%
Between $60,000 and $79,99918.9%38.9%26.3%15.8%
Between $80,000 and $99,99934.9%34.0%18.9%12.3%
$100,000 or more31.8%39.2%22.2%6.8%
Political Spectrum
Right31.5%40.7%20.4%7.4%
Right of center28.2%37.3%30.0%4.5%
Center28.7%44.4%19.1%7.9%
Left of center32.2%31.0%25.3%11.5%
Left40.8%28.6%14.3%16.3%
Table 2b. Canadians’ intentions to get a third vaccine booster (Wave 4 data).

In October 2022 (Wave 5), less than one in four Canadians (23.3%) who had received the initial two doses of a COVID-19 vaccine intended to get a third booster dose. However, more than half of Canadians (52.5%) who had already received a third dose of the vaccine intended to get a fourth dose (second booster shot).

While the rates presented in Tables 3a and 3b below (Wave 5) are not directly comparable to those in Tables 2a and 2b above (Wave 4) due to different response options, we can look to the ‘No’ column in both tables to see the proportion of Canadians who have no intentions to get a booster shot. In Wave 4 (Feb.-Mar. 2022), 37 percent of Canadians (who had received 2 doses) indicated that they would not get a third booster shot, while in Wave 5 this increased to 56 percent (See Figure 3a).

Men were somewhat more likely to get booster vaccines (27% responding ‘Yes’ to getting a third shot and 54% for the fourth shot) compared to females (20% and 51%), but these differences were not statistically significant. Older Canadians were generally more receptive to getting booster shots, especially those who already had three COVID-19 vaccines: 56% of Canadians age 65 and up were willing to get a fourth shot against COVID-19 while less than 46% of those 18 to 24 intended to get a fourth dose (X² = 25.32, p <.01).

Wave 5 (October 2022)Do you intend to get a 3rd booster vaccine?Do you intend to get a 4th booster vaccine?
YesNoI don’t knowYesNoI don’t know
Total23.3%55.6%21.1%52.5%21.4%26.1%
Sex
Male26.6%52.5%20.9%54.2%21.9%23.9%
Female20.2%58.5%21.3%50.7%21.0%28.4%
Age
Between 18 and 2421.6%50.5%27.8%45.6%26.5%27.9%
Between 25 and 3423.6%57.7%18.7%46.7%29.7%23.6%
Between 35 and 4427.3%61.0%11.7%50.4%21.8%27.7%
Between 45 and 5417.6%54.9%27.5%54.7%20.1%25.2%
Between 55 and 6427.6%49.4%23.0%56.2%17.0%26.8%
65 and older15.4%53.8%30.8%58.3%15.8%25.9%
Ethnicity
White23.8%56.2%20.0%52.5%21.0%26.5%
Indigenous19.0%47.6%33.3%53.2%21.3%25.5%
Black11.8%66.7%21.6%38.7%32.3%29.0%
Asian34.6%50.6%14.8%55.1%20.5%24.4%
Other17.0%57.4%25.5%52.5%19.7%27.9%
Immigrant status
Immigrant27.8%52.7%19.5%52.4%19.3%28.3%
Non-Immigrant21.6%56.7%21.6%52.4%22.0%25.6%
Table 3a. Canadians’ intentions to get third and fourth vaccine boosters (Wave 5 data).

Ethnicity was an important predictor of booster uptake for the third vaccine, but not the fourth. Asian Canadians were much more willing to get a third shot (35% ‘Yes’ and 15% ‘I don’t know’) compared to Black Canadians (12% ‘Yes’ and 22% ‘I don’t know’). The Chi-Square test indicates significant differences between groups in terms of booster uptake (X² = 15.70, p <.05). While slight differences existed with regard to immigrant and Canadian-born’ intentions to get a third dose they were not significant. There were however geographic differences present regarding intentions to get a fourth dose: 63% of British Columbians were willing to get a second booster dose compared to less than half of Quebecers and Ontario residents (X² = 22.22, p <.05) (See Figure 3b).

Education and income were also important predictors of vaccine uptake. Canadians with a university bachelor’s degree or higher, for instance, were 9.5% more likely to get a fourth shot compared to those with a high school education or less (X² = 16.14, p <.05) and households that earned more than $80,000 per year were twice as likely to get a third shot compared to low-income households earning less than $20,000 (X² = 28.55, p <.001).

Where Canadians place themselves along the political spectrum also has a major impact on their likelihood of getting COVID-19 boosters, with left leaners being much more willing to get boosters than the right. Around two in five Canadians who positioned themselves left of center were willing to get a third dose and seven in 10 were willing to get a fourth dose. On the other hand, only about one in five Canadians to the right of the political spectrum considered getting a third dose and just over half were willing to get a fourth dose. Chi-square tests were significant across both analysis of political spectrum and vaccine hesitancy (X² = 24.47, p <.01 for 3rd dose and X² = 28.38, p <.001 for 4th dose).

Wave 5 (October 2022)Do you intend to get a 3rd booster vaccine?Do you intend to get a 4th booster vaccine?
YesNoI don’t knowYesNoI don’t know
Total23.3%55.6%21.1%52.5%21.4%26.1%
Province
British Columbia30.8%50.0%19.2%63.3%16.1%20.6%
Alberta25.3%53.8%20.9%51.2%17.6%31.2%
Prairies14.6%58.3%27.1%62.0%19.0%19.0%
Ontario24.8%54.0%21.2%49.1%23.2%27.7%
Quebec16.3%64.4%19.3%47.7%25.8%26.5%
Maritimes25.9%51.7%22.4%53.6%17.9%28.6%
Education
High school or less16.6%60.9%22.5%48.0%23.5%28.5%
Postsecondary schooling26.9%53.1%20.0%52.0%21.4%26.6%
University bachelor degree or higher23.9%55.6%20.6%57.5%20.1%22.4%
Income
$19,999 or less17.5%52.6%29.8%37.2%26.7%36.0%
Between $20,000 and $39,99930.9%43.2%25.9%52.2%17.9%29.9%
Between $40,000 and $59,99922.0%54.0%24.0%51.7%21.0%27.3%
Between $60,000 and $79,99913.2%69.2%17.6%67.8%17.2%14.9%
Between $80,000 and $99,99936.4%47.5%16.2%46.5%20.8%32.6%
$100,000 or more22.2%64.2%13.6%53.2%25.8%21.1%
Right21.2%75.0%3.8%40.7%32.2%27.1%
Right of center22.8%59.8%17.4%55.1%27.8%17.0%
Center29.6%48.6%21.8%58.5%20.3%21.2%
Left of center41.5%44.6%13.8%66.1%14.9%19.0%
Left38.2%35.3%26.5%71.2%9.3%19.5%
Table 3b. Canadians’ intentions to get third and fourth vaccine boosters (Wave 5 data).

Vaccine hesitancy—qualitative analysis

Following up on the question about the intention to get a third booster vaccine in wave 5 (October 2022), we asked respondents who did not intend to get the booster to give us an open-ended response to their reasoning behind it. Four main themes (or reasons) emerged from those responses which are summarized as follows:

  • Questioning the efficacy of the vaccine
  • Unwillingness to risk the side-effects anymore
  • Lack of trust in government and pharmaceutical companies
  • Claiming enough immunity after two vaccines (and/or catching COVID-19)

These themes are also reflected in a word-cloud (Figure 2) generated from a query for the 50 most frequent words (relevant filters applied) in the responses. Moreover, Table 4 shows some of the detailed excerpts that highlight the emerging themes from the responses.

Summary and conclusion

Vaccine uptake varies considerably across demographic groups in Canada. As of spring 2022 (Wave 4), males, elders (and youth), Asian Canadians, immigrants, BC and Maritimes residents were all more likely to get third vaccines (boosters). University graduates and households earning $100,000 or more were also more likely to get booster shots along with those to the left of the political spectrum. Similar patterns were observed in the fall of 2022 (Wave 5) in regard to getting third and fourth vaccines, however it should be noted that there was significant drop-off in booster uptake (i.e., increased booster hesitancy) among those who had just two vaccines. In the final survey wave, less than one in four Canadians definitively stated that they would get a third booster (another one in five were unsure); however, the majority of Canadians who already had three COVID-19 vaccines intended to get a fourth (53% stated ‘Yes’ and 26% stated ‘I don’t know’).

Word cloud in shades of grey, with larger type for more frequent words. The largest words are necessary, effects, trust, enough, booster, first, still, sick, side and people. The other words printed are protect, mandatory, deadly, ineffective, strong, companies, affect, completely, cold, health, system, prevent, order, caught, second, seem, stop, spread, mild, never, sure, reaction, variant, things, useless, third, wait, risk, point, time, government, already, done, difference, months, symptoms, help, long, pharmaceutical and interested.

See page 40 of the PDF (opens in a new tab)

Figure 2. Word cloud of responses to “Why do you not intend to get the 3rd vaccine dose?”
ThemeExcerpt
Questioning the efficacy of the vaccine“The first two vaccine shots didn’t work and I’ve seen no evidence that a third is necessary or effective. I’m also worried about the safety of the vaccine…why risk my health on a third dose of an unproven, unsafe and ineffective vaccine to prevent getting a cold?”
“Don’t think it has much effect on the variants, and the variants are less dangerous so don’t mind getting it”
Unwillingness to risk the side-effects“The first 2 didn’t prevent me from getting COVID-19. Risk of side effects is too high. I have an immune system, this is not a deadly virus.”
“I’ve experienced very bad symptoms with the first two doses. With my health declining so rapidly in the last two years I just cannot justify the risk for the potential benefit, if any at all.”
Lack of trust in government and pharmaceutical companies“Don’t trust the government or pharmaceutical companies giving it.”
“Because I still had COVID-19 and the vaccine gave me more serious side effects than COVID-19 and it’s not normal to get vaccinated at every turn, I do not trust the authorities that govern us or the powers of money that prevent us from living freely”
Claiming enough immunity after two vaccines (and/or catching COVID-19)“I’m tired of the repeated “booster” requirements. I feel we are now at the stage where natural immunity is high and I still take preventive steps when dealing with the public.”
“I think two is enough. Considering I have not contracted the virus since it’s beginning in 2020 I am confident in my immune system. I would take a 3rd dose maybe 4-6 years from now. I’ll wait for science to do more research on the long-term effects of the vaccine and the virus.”
Table 4. Quotes from respondents regarding vaccine booster hesitancy

It seems that by the fall of 2022, Canadians had made up their mind about vaccination: those who had not yet received their third dose probably weren’t going to do so while those who had received their third dose were more likely than not to get a fourth dose.

The key findings of this study alert us to some challenges in the future regarding COVID-19 booster vaccines and vaccines in general. Vaccine uptake has waned over time in Canada, dropping from around 6 in 10 double-vaccinated Canadians who at least considered getting a third dose (booster shot) in the spring of 2022 to around 4 in 10 Canadians in the fall of 2022. More research is needed to understand why exactly this is, but some possible explanations may be tied to the public discourse and the mixed messaging that Canadians are exposed to in the media. Initially messaging (and regulations surrounding vaccine passports) indicated that two doses would be sufficient and many Canadians may have held onto that information for the long haul. “Younger, healthy people don’t need another COVID-19 booster, according to vaccine experts” is also a common headline in the media recently, based on studies such as Dr. Paul Offit’s “Bivalent COVID-19 Vaccines — A Cautionary Tale,” in the New England Journal of Medicine (January 2023). The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has also issued public statements throughout the pandemic suggesting that booster shots are not immediately necessary among the fully vaccinated (two doses) or that Americans under the age of 50 can wait to get fourth doses (see Rutherford & Castronuovo, Bloomberg News, April 20, 2022). With this seemingly contradictory information, not to mention the many sources of disinformation that pervade social media platforms, it is no wonder that Canadians are in no rush to continue getting COVID-19 boosters.

References

  • Offit, Paul. “Bivalent COVID-19 Vaccines - A Cautionary Tale”, The New England Journal of Medicine, 2023, https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2215780
  • Bowman, Emma, “Despite New COVID Variants, CDC Says You Don’t Need Any Boosters Right Now,” NPR, 2021, https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2021/07/08/1014438902/despite-new-covid-variants-cdc-says-you-dont-need-any-booster-doses-right-now
  • Rutherford, Fiona and Castronuovo, Celine, “Most People Under 40 Don’t Need 4th Shot Yet, CDC Panel Suggests”, Bloomberrg, 2022, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-20/most-people-under-50-don-t-need-4th-shot-yet-cdc-panel-suggests?leadSource=uverify%20wall

About the authors

Paul Holley

Paul Holley is the Research Director at the Association for Canadian Studies and Metropolis Institute (ACS-Metropolis). His current research focuses on the development of a sustainable housing index for Nunavut, the social determinants of (mental) health, anti-racism initiatives and immigrant integration and inclusion in Canada. Paul received a PhD in Sociology with an emphasis on Global Studies in 2006 from Arizona State University.

Ravindra Shrestha

Ravindra Shrestha is a Research Manager at Association for Canadian Studies (ACS). He is currently working on two key research projects at ACS related to housing in Canada’s northern communities and ‘Canadian Index for Measuring Integration and Inclusion (CIMII)’. He has extensive experience in policy research, data analysis and survey management gained through working with the public sector and international development agencies. He received his Master’s in Agricultural Engineering from Purdue University.

Cite this article

Holley, P., & Shrestha, R. (2023). Booster Vaccine Uptake and Hesitancy in Canada from February to October 2022. Canadian Diversity, 19(1), 34–41. https://acs-metropolis.ca/en/library/canadian-diversity/vol-19-no-1-2023/booster-vaccine-uptake-and-hesitancy-in-canada-from-february-to-october-2022

Back to the issue

Stay up to date

Register for our mailing list to get our latest research, publications, event reminders and webinar announcements.