Supporting Newcomer Pathways Into the Labour Market

Download this article (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Download the full issue (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Download the French edition (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Read this article in French

Canada’s immigration system places an emphasis on education and professional experience. However, many highly skilled newcomers to Canada often end up working in precarious, low-skilled jobs and have difficulties accessing job opportunities aligned with their competencies (Lauer et al., 2013). Education and training can provide a bridge to commensurate employment, provided that supports are present to help newcomers access, succeed in and exploit the learnings from these programs. ESDC defines wraparound support as “A set of supports or services provided to an individual, particularly, though not exclusively, from an Indigenous and/or equity-deserving group, that are necessary to mitigate barriers to their participation in the project.”1 Wraparound supports may also be viewed more broadly and in relation to the participant’s experience throughout the program access, program completion and employment outcomes phases of skills development interventions.2 There is a pressing need to learn more about what wraparound supports are, why they are important and how wraparound supports can be incorporated to help service providers and government agencies advance meaningful and effective programs tailored to the needs of newcomers. In this article, we identify a set of examples according to factors, such as place of service, type of service provider and immigration status of its users, in order to review a cross-section of existing wraparound supports. In doing so, we aim to make recommendations for a more coordinated system level approach.

There are complex reasons why newcomers are not able to access jobs compatible with their education or experience. Some of these reasons relate to the skills, knowledge and social capital newcomers possess, and some relate to systemic barriers and discrimination, including the lack of recognition of credentials, bias in the hiring processes, and challenges with the design and implementation of programs.3 Canada invests heavily in training to support newcomers, ranging from language training to bridging programs through a variety of mechanisms at the federal, provincial and municipal levels. Additionally, postsecondary institutions, private colleges, and training organizations purport to provide pathways to employment. While education and training are the backbone of social mobility in Canada, the results are uneven. Many newcomers face barriers to accessing and succeeding in training programs, and recent research suggests that a more nuanced understanding of the career pathing journey for newcomers and inclusive wraparound supports are key to improving outcomes. Figure 1, below, outlines each stage of the career-pathing journey. This framework can be used to assess support requirements throughout the journey, with a direct link to career outcomes.

At each stage of the career pathing journey, some newcomers face challenges. Deciding to pursue training is a daunting proposition in light of many competing priorities.4 Building self-efficacy, particularly for those who have experienced trauma or bias in dealing with institutions, may require additional psychological support.5 Navigating systems, supports, unfamiliar job applications and interview processes, and building social capital can overwhelm even experienced and well-resourced professionals.6 Newcomers may require targeted training and coaching as well as sponsorship and mentoring. Coping with socio-economic barriers including finances, access to housing, transportation (particularly in smaller communities), child care, or even a wardrobe needed for the job may be challenging. There are also intersectional considerations such as the additional burden women may face because of gender role expectations and unpaid work (e.g., child care, elder care, and household tasks).7 Skills programs must meet participants where they are at while recognizing the unique complexities of their lives. Wraparound supports to address human capital barriers (e.g., tuition reimbursement), for example, may fail in the absence of strategies fulfilling logistical (e.g., childcare), well-being and labour market access needs.

A row of six coloured circles with line icons, each with a stage name above and a short description below, read left to right as one sentence. 1. Encouraging user entry (light blue circle, a person walking toward an open door): Users need an entryway into the lifelong learning ecosystem. 2. Building self-efficacy (blue circle, a person climbing steps to a flag): a belief they can succeed throughout the journey. 3. Navigating careers and systems (teal circle, a person walking toward a signpost under a cloud and sun): a clean view of the pathway to success. 4. Assisting with economic and social barriers (green circle, a woman holding a child): help managing barriers like childcare and financial insecurity. 5. Providing good content and good teaching (yellow circle, a person pointing at a board): scaffolded, engaging, and positivety affirming content. 6. Sustaining support (orange circle, two clasped hands): and continued support for on-the-job success and lifelong learning.

See page 43 of the PDF (opens in a new tab)

Figure 1. Career-pathing model. Source: Escobari, M., Seyal, I., & Meaney, M. (2019). Realism about reskilling: Upgrading the career prospects of America’s low-wage workers. Brookings. www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Realism-about-Reskilling_Brookings_Overview-FOR-WEB.pdf

As more and more programs require access to technology, the costs of networks, devices and the skills to use them may be a barrier. For example, neighbourhoods with large racialized and immigrant populations are less likely to have access to high speed internet and to devices such as smartphones and laptops.8 A recent study by Diversity Institute, Future Skills Centre and the Environics Institute identified that the cost of high-speed internet in Toronto was more likely to be a concern among racialized families.9 While, increasingly there is evidence to suggest that wraparound supports may be as critical to success as the training itself, research on the topic has been limited.10 This is partly due to the lack of consensus on the definition of wraparound support and partly due to the dearth of evaluations that isolate its impact. In a review of 175 programs targeting newcomers and other underserved communities, only three percent had available evaluations.11 This review also found the application of wraparound supports to be uneven across sectors and providers. The non-profit sector was most likely to offer supports (117 of the 175 programs; 67 percent), followed by programs delivered by, or in collaboration with private sector organizations (e.g., supports associated with NPower Canada’s Junior IT Analyst Program, delivered in partnership with Google) and less commonly, by government. Few support programs were offered in association with formal educational service providers, such as colleges and universities.

Common service combinations

A recent review of wraparound supports for skills training programs showed that while definitions vary and there is considerable fragmentation in services, many organizations have built wraparound supports for newcomers into their programs.12 A thematic analysis revealed that supports were designed to address three types of newcomer jobseeker needs: 1) human capital needs (e.g., direct financial support for training); 2) logistical needs (e.g., childcare, providing laptops); and, 3) well-being and motivational needs (e.g., counseling and coaching).

Supports to address newcomer jobseekers’ human capital needs are common and may include employment placements, subsidies or lump-sum payments at the end of training completion or tuition, textbook and living expense reimbursements. For example, the Government of Quebec’s Employment Integration Program for Immigrants and Visible Minorities (PRIIME) provides payments to immigrants in training, job placements and provides other settlement supports. To support newcomers’ skill commensurate employment, PRIIME provides a 30-week wage subsidy to employers when newcomers are hired on their own initiative or through the assistance of Services Québec.13 Manitoba Start’s WorkStart work-experience program provides immigrant youth with mentoring support and eight weeks paid work experience in roles aligned with their interests, education and skills.14 Work integrated learning and mentorship provide two of the most effective ways of improving the labour market outcomes of newcomers. These programs help newcomers acquire work experience within the Canadian context, develop their networks and build their social capital.15 Further, work integrated learning allows participants to earn while they learn. Alternative financing options are also available through organizations such as Windmill Microlending, a national not-for-profit that offers low interest loans to skilled immigrants and refugees to pay for the costs of recertifying or getting licensed in Canada. As an organization, it collaborates with skills trainers to help newcomers access loans to finance their skill development.16

Many organizations provide logistical supports, such as childcare, transit or digital devices and internet connectivity, to help newcomers access opportunities. The Riverdale Immigrant Women’s Centre, Times Change Women’s Employment Service Inc., and WoodGreen Community Services, all provide laptop loans and internet services to participants who lack suitable access.17 Unfortunately, technology supports appear to be scarce outside of Toronto. St. Stephen’s Community House helps newcomers with free English as a Second Language training and provides childcare and transit subsidies to meet logistical needs and enable participation.18 The Newcomer Entrepreneurship Hub (NEH), created by the Diversity Institute in partnership with SCCC, delivers professional training to newcomers while enabling their achievement through wraparound supports (e.g., translation and settlement support). To date, 37 businesses have been successfully launched by program graduates and individualized business mentors support their journey.19

Often human capital and logistical supports are combined with mentoring, counseling, coaching and psycho-social supports. For example, Scadding Court Community Centre’s Newcomer Services Program offers counseling, networking, childcare support and cultural-competency training with assistance navigating the employment and settlement services ecosystem.20 Some programs have strong connections with employers to provide targeted career support. Since 2004, Toronto Region Immigrant Employment Council’s (TRIEC) Mentorship Partnership program has matched over 22,000 immigrants with established professionals in their field, resulting in improved labour force outcomes.21 Other organizations in the Immigrant Employer Network, such as the Immigrant Employment Council of British Columbia (IECBC) offer innovative solutions including pre-arrival training.22 The TRIEC Mentorship partnership resulted in participants being 2.45 times more likely to have quality employment and other employer centered programs such as Diversity Institute’s Advanced Digital and Professional Training (ADaPT) program have demonstrated promising results.23

Increasingly there is recognition of the importance of trauma informed approaches. The Ontario Council of Agencies Serving Immigrants (OCASI), has developed a promising set of guidelines for organizations, however, acute shortages in access to tailored mental health supports remain a challenge.24 Organizations such as the Ismaili Institutions for Canada have identified this as part of their efforts to resettle refugees as have Catholic Crosscultural Services (CCS), particularly in their work with refugees.25 Organizations such as Green Shield Canada and Inkblot are experimenting with new online culturally appropriate approaches.26 Community support, networks and social capital are also critical.27

The cited examples provide emerging best practices; however, at the system level challenges remain as a result of the fragmentation of training programs and support services in the Canadian ecosystem. This makes it difficult for newcomers to navigate programs, eligibility requirements and applications, especially if they are working in English as a Second Language. Additionally, as there is little system level organization, quality control or support in navigating programs, many newcomers are vulnerable to poorly designed or even predatory programs, which offer training for jobs that never materialize.

Conclusion: toward inclusive wraparound supports

While our understanding of the design and impact of wraparound services is evolving, and more research is needed, there is strong evidence to suggest that a more intentional approach will yield better results. Organizing current supports around the needs of newcomer job seekers as they pertain to their human capital needs, logistical needs, and well-being and motivational needs will help to direct relevant policy and the development of future services, as well as the efforts of government agencies, and other service providers. In doing so, however, we must:

  • Ensure consistency in the definition, delivery, and evaluation of wraparound services.
  • Provide better access to information about these supports, such as an accessible, centralized database of services.
  • Reduce fragmentation, promote cooperation and the sharing of innovative and effective practices, perhaps offering shared services to develop economies of scale.
  • Increase employer engagement in the career counseling and wraparound supports.
  • Recognize that up front investments (with accountability frameworks) in well designed and effective programs will save money over the longer term and drive economic growth and inclusion not just for newcomers but for the country as a whole.

Ensure all programs have a trauma-informed and intersectional lens applied to them and that trainers and counselors as well as recruiters understand the specific challenges facing newcomers.

Education and training are foundational to social mobility in Canada and wraparound supports can help newcomers access important education and training opportunities. We recommend applying a broad definition of wraparound support that is inclusive of provisions such as childcare, transportation subsidies, food subsidies, technology access, career counseling, mentorship services, networking support, direct financial support, mental health support, and work placement services.28

Finally, there is a need for greater coordination between training providers and the community-based organizations and postsecondary institutions providing wraparound. It is also critical that program metrics be identified and operationalized to facilitate robust evaluations, both of employment-training interventions and of the impact of wraparound supports on newcomer success. Finally, a systems approach that prioritizes coordination and alignment between all levels of government, educational institutions, community-based organizations, and employers is requisite. Attention to wraparound supports can facilitate newcomers’ participation in employment-training interventions, accelerating the process of social and economic integration and setting the foundation for full and equitable participation.

Notes

  1. Government of Canada. (2022). Apply for funding to support workers and employers towards economic recovery - Sectoral Workforce Solutions Program – Closed. Employment and Social Development Canada. www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/services/funding/sectoral-workforce-solutions-economic-recovery.html 1
  2. Wendy Cukier et al., Wraparound Supports for Skills Development: Designing and Implementing Programs for Indigenous Peoples and Equity-Deserving Groups (Toronto: Diversity Institute, 2022). 2
  3. Feenan, Katherine & Shamira Madhany. (2021). Skills for the Post-pandemic World: Immigration and the Success of Canada’s Post-Pandemic Economy. May 2021. www.torontomu.ca/diversity/reports/ImmigrationAndCanadasPostpandemicEconomy.pdf 3
  4. Chen, Wen-Hao and Feng Hou. (2019). Intergenerational Education Mobility and Labour Market Outcomes: Variation Among the Second Generation of Immigrants in Canada. Statistics Canada, Analytical Studies Branch Research Paper Series. www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11f0019m/11f0019m2019006-eng.htm 4
  5. Kopala, Mary and Merle Keital (Eds.). (2003). Handbook of Counseling Women. Sage Publications Inc., California USA. 5
  6. Escobari, Marcel, Ian Seyal and Michael Meaney. 2019. “About Reskilling Upgrading the career prospects of America’s low-wage workers.” Workforce of the Future initiative, Brookings Institute. www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Realism-about-Reskilling_Brookings_Overview-FOR-WEB.pdf 6
  7. Coogan, Pauline A., & Professor Charles P. Chen (2007) Career development and counselling for women: Connecting theories to practice, Counselling Psychology Quarterly, 20:2, 191-204, DOI: 10.1080/09515070701391171 7
  8. Andrey, S., Dorkenoo, S., Malli, N., & Masoodi, M. (2021). Mapping Toronto's digital divide. Brookfield Institute. https://brookfieldinstitute.ca/mapping-torontos-digital-divide 8
  9. Wendy Cukier et al., Wraparound Supports for Skills Development: Designing and Implementing Programs for Indigenous Peoples and Equity-Deserving Groups (Toronto: Diversity Institute, 2022). 9
  10. Ibid. 10
  11. Ibid. 11
  12. Diversity Institute. (2021). Pathways to Innovation and Inclusion. Canadian Diversity, Volume 18, NO. 2, 2021. www.torontomu.ca/content/dam/diversity/reports/642_AEC_CanDiv_-vol18no2_EN_V2_LR-2.pdf 12
  13. Government of Quebec. (2023). www.quebec.ca/en/employment/find-job-internship/employment-assistance-programs/immigrants-visible-minorities/employment-integration 13
  14. Manitoba Start. (2022). WorkStart Work Experience program. https://manitobastart.com/for-newcomers/work-experience-programs 14
  15. Wendy Cukier et al., Wraparound Supports for Skills Development: Designing and Implementing Programs for Indigenous Peoples and Equity-Deserving Groups (Toronto: Diversity Institute, 2022). 15
  16. Windmill Microlending. (2023). https://windmillmicrolending.org/applicants/eligibility 16
  17. Riverdale Immigrant Women’s Centre (n.d.). www.riwc.ca; Times Change Women’s Employment Centre (n.d.). www.timeschange.org; WoodGreen programs (n.d.). www.woodgreen.org 17
  18. TNG Community Services. (2023). https://tngcommunityto.org 18
  19. Wendy Cukier, Wendy, Guang Ying Mo, Bincy Wilson, Stefan Karajovic and Nicholas Renzetti. (2022). Wraparound Supports for Skills Development: Designing and Implementing Programs for Indigenous Peoples and Equity-Deserving Groups. Diversity Institute, Forthcoming. 19
  20. SCCC. (2023). https://scaddingcourt.org 20
  21. TRIEC. (2020). Demand for & Impact of Mentoring Newcomer Professionals: The case of TRIEC Mentoring Partnership - Evaluation Findings. https://triec.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Demand-for-Impact-of-Mentoring-Newcomer-Professionals-The-case-of-TRIEC-Mentoring-Partnership.pdf 21
  22. IECBC. (2023). https://iecbc.ca/our-work/programs 22
  23. TRIEC. (2020). Demand for & Impact of Mentoring Newcomer Professionals: The case of TRIEC Mentoring Partnership - Evaluation Findings. https://triec.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Demand-for-Impact-of-Mentoring-Newcomer-Professionals-The-case-of-TRIEC-Mentoring-Partnership.pdf, Diversity Institute. (2023). ADaPT (Advanced Digital and Professional Training). www.torontomu.ca/adapt 23
  24. OCASI. (2023). OCASI Guidelines on Trauma and Violence Informed Approaches for Agencies Serving Immigrants and Refugees. https://ocasi.org/sites/default/files/tvia-guide-english-online.pdf 24
  25. Ismaili Institutions for Canada. (2023). https://iicanada.org/health-wellness CCS. 2023. www.cathcrosscultural.org/newcomer-support-services 25
  26. Green Shied Canada. (2021). Better Health for All. 2021 Social Impact Report. https://assets.greenshield.ca/greenshield/2022/blog/pdfs/GSC-2021-Social-Impact-Report-EN-Final-REV-Remediated.pdf 26
  27. Cukier, W. and S. Jackson. (2017). Welcoming Syrian refugees to Canada technology-enabled social innovation. 2017 IEEE Canada International Humanitarian Technology Conference (IHTC), Toronto, ON, Canada, 2017, pp. 32-36, doi: 10.1109/IHTC.2017.8058194 27
  28. Wendy Cukier, Wendy, Guang Ying Mo, Bincy Wilson, Stefan Karajovic and Nicholas Renzetti. (2022). Wraparound Supports for Skills Development: Designing and Implementing Programs for Indigenous Peoples and Equity-Deserving Groups. Diversity Institute, Forthcoming. 28

References

  • Advanced Digital and Professional Training (ADaPT). Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. www.torontomu.ca/adapt
  • Andrey, Sam, Selasi Dorkenoo, Nisa Malli, and Mohammed Masoodi. Mapping Toronto's Digital Divide. Toronto: Brookfield Institute, 2021. https://brookfieldinstitute.ca/mapping-torontos-digital-divide
  • Catholic Crosscultural Service (CCS). Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. www.cathcrosscultural.org/newcomer-support-services
  • Chen, Wen-Hao, and Feng Hou. Intergenerational Education Mobility and Labour Market Outcomes: Variation Among the Second Generation of Immigrants in Canada. Analytical Studies Branch Research Paper Series. Ottawa: Statistics Canada, February 2019. www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11f0019m/11f0019m2019006-eng.htm
  • Coogan, Pauline A., and Charles P. Chen. “Career Development and Counselling for Women: Connecting Theories to Practice.” Counseling Psychology Quarterly 20, no. 2 (2007): 191-204. https://doi.org/10.1080/09515070701391171
  • Cukier, Wendy, Guang Ying Mo, Bincy Wilson, Stefan Karajovic, and Nicholas Renzetti. Wraparound Supports for Skills Development: Designing and Implementing Programs for Indigenous Peoples and Equity-Deserving Groups. Toronto: Diversity Institute, 2022.
  • Cukier, Wendy, and Samantha Jackson. “Welcoming Syrian Refugees to Canada Technology-enabled Social Innovation.” In 2017 IEEE Canada International Humanitarian Technology Conference (IHTC), Toronto, 2017, 32-36. Doi: 10.1109/IHTC.2017.8058194
  • Diversity Institute. “Pathways to Innovation and Inclusion.” Canadian Diversity 18, no. 2 (2021): 1-48. www.torontomu.ca/content/dam/diversity/reports/642_AEC_CanDiv_-vol18no2_EN_V2_LR-2.pdf
  • Escobari, Marcelo, Ian Seyal, and Michael Meaney. Realism About Reskilling: Upgrading the Career Prospects of America’s Low-wage Workers. Washington, DC: Brookings, 2019. www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Realism-about-Reskilling_Brookings_Overview-FOR-WEB.pdf
  • Feenan, Katherine, and Shamira Madhany. Skills for the Post-pandemic World: Immigration and the Success of Canada’s Post-Pandemic Economy. Toronto: Diversity Institute, 2021. www.torontomu.ca/diversity/reports/ImmigrationAndCanadasPostpandemicEconomy.pdf
  • Green Shield Canada. Better Health for All - 2021 Social Impact Report (Windsor: Green Shield Canada, 2022). https://assets.greenshield.ca/greenshield/2022/blog/pdfs/GSC-2021-Social-Impact-Report-EN-Final-REV-Remediated.pdf
  • Government of Canada. “Apply for Funding to Support Workers and Employers Towards Economic Recovery - Sectoral Workforce Solutions Program." Employment and Social Development Canada. Last modified April 4, 2022. www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/services/funding/sectoral-workforce-solutions-economic-recovery.html
  • Government of Quebec. “Employment Integration for Immigrants and Visible Minorities.” Last modified July 6, 2023. www.quebec.ca/en/employment/find-job-internship/employment-assistance-programs/immigrants-visible-minorities/employment-integration
  • Immigrant Employment Council of BC (IECBC). Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. https://iecbc.ca/our-work/programs
  • Ismaili Institutions for Canada. Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. https://iicanada.org/health-wellness
  • Kopala, Mary, and Merle Keital, eds. Handbook of Counseling Women. California: Sage Publications Inc., 2003.
  • Manitoba Start. “WorkStart Work Experience Program.” Accessed September 5, 2023. https://manitobastart.com/for-newcomers/work-experience-programs
  • Ontario Council of Agencies Serving Immigrants (OCASI). OCASI Guidelines on Trauma and Violence Informed Approaches for Agencies Serving Immigrants and Refugees (Toronto: OCASI, 2023). https://ocasi.org/sites/default/files/tvia-guide-english-online.pdf
  • Riverdale Immigrant Women’s Centre. Homepage. Accessed September 5. 2023. www.riwc.ca
  • Scadding Court Community Centre (SCCC). Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. https://scaddingcourt.org
  • Times Change Women’s Employment Centre. Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. www.timeschange.org
  • TNG Community Services. Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. https://tngcommunityto.org
  • Toronto Region Immigrant Employment Council (TRIEC). Demand for & Impact of Mentoring Newcomer Professionals: The Case of TRIEC Mentoring Partnership - Evaluation Findings (Toronto: TRIEC, February 2020). https://triec.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Demand-for-Impact-of-Mentoring-Newcomer-Professionals-The-case-of-TRIEC-Mentoring-Partnership.pdf.
  • Windmill Microlending. “Return to your Profession Today.” Accessed September 5, 2023. https://windmillmicrolending.org/applicants/eligibility
  • WoodGreen programs. Homepage. Accessed September 5, 2023. www.woodgreen.org

About the authors

Shamira Madhany

Shamira Madhany joined WES in 2018 after more than two decades of government service in Ontario. She is a transformative leader and passionate advocate for a more inclusive Canada. Shamira served as the chief architect of several government cutting-edge programs that break down barriers to equality, helping to enable internationally educated professionals to obtain employment in their fields and newcomers to integrate into Canadian life. She serves on the boards of Windmill Microlending, Shad Canada, Herzing College Toronto, and CERC Migration Stakeholder Advisory Board at Toronto Metropolitan University. She is a recipient of the 2023 International Alliance for Women (TIAW) World of Difference Award, and the 2020 Metropolis Policy Maker Award of Excellence.

Wendy Cukier

Wendy Cukier is a professor of Entrepreneurship and Strategy at the Ted Rogers School of Management, Founder and Academic Director of the Diversity Institute at Toronto Metropolitan University, Academic Director of the Women’s Entrepreneurship Knowledge Hub (WEKH) and Research Lead of the Future Skills Centre. She co-authored the bestseller “Innovation Nation: Canadian Leadership From Java to Jurassic Park”; and is a leader in disruptive technologies and innovation. She is the former vice-president of Research and Innovation at Toronto Metropolitan University and has authored more than 200 articles on diversity, inclusion and innovation. She holds a PhD in Information Systems, an MBA, an MA, and honorary doctorates from Laval and Concordia. She received Canada’s Meritorious Service Cross, one of Canada’s highest civilian honours.

Cite this article

Madhany, S., & Cukier, W. (2023). Supporting Newcomer Pathways Into the Labour Market. Canadian Diversity, 19(4), 42–47. https://acs-metropolis.ca/en/library/canadian-diversity/vol-19-no-4-2023/supporting-newcomer-pathways-into-the-labour-market

Back to the issue

Stay up to date

Register for our mailing list to get our latest research, publications, event reminders and webinar announcements.