Confronting misinformation

The rise of Holocaust skepticism and its sources: A Canadian case study

Download this article (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Download the full issue (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Download the French edition (PDF) (opens in a new tab)Read this article in French

Introduction

Some one in six Canadians between the ages of 18 and 24 believe that the Holocaust is exaggerated. These are among several worrisome findings from a Fall 2024 survey (Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies). It’s a view shared by a similar percentage of Americans in the same age group (overall, this view is held by five percent of Canadians and eight percent of Americans). Denial and distortion about the Holocaust remain critical concerns in Canada and elsewhere. Holocaust denial is widely subjected to legislative sanction, and there is a continued need for vigilance in this regard. But addressing the view that the Holocaust is exaggerated may present a different challenge for contemporary educators and policymakers.

We use the term "Holocaust skepticism" to describe the view that the Holocaust is exaggerated. Its proponents are referred to as Holocaust skeptics. This study examines the extent of such beliefs, their potential sources, and the underlying sentiments driving these worrisome perspectives.

The data

As observed in the Table 1, five percent of Canadians agree that the Holocaust is exaggerated, with the percentage dropping below four percent among Canadians over 45 years old. Overall, over one in seven Canadians (13%) say they don’t know or prefer not to answer. The extent to which this view is held by persons aged 18 to 24 stands in stark contrast to those in the 45+ cohort.

Persuading skeptics will not be simple. As seen in Table 2, Holocaust skeptics often believe they have a good knowledge of genocides across history. Among those who think the Holocaust is exaggerated, two-thirds claim good knowledge about historical genocides.

Why do they believe the Holocaust is exaggerated?

To better understand the reasoning behind Holocaust skepticism, we asked individuals holding this view to explain their stance in one sentence. As shown in Table 3, the responses are vague, with the principal observation being that the Holocaust receives too much attention.

I think the Holocaust is exaggeratedCanada total18–2425–3435–4445–5455–6465+
Yes5%16%8%5%4%3%2%
No82%69%78%78%81%85%91%
I don’t know / Prefer not to answer13%15%15%17%15%12%7%
Table 1. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024.
I have a good knowledge about genocides in historyI think the Holocaust is exaggerated (yes)I think the Holocaust is exaggerated (no)
Yes66%55%
No32%35%
I don’t know / Prefer not to answer2%10%
Total100%100%
Table 2. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024.
Why do you think the Holocaust is exaggerated?Percentage
Overreacting/Overly publicized (in media, books, movies, etc.)19%
Lack of access to the full truth/Need for unbiased history8%
Discrepancies in numbers/Difficult to verify the exact figures7%
Not the worst event in history/Not just Jews suffered6%
Attracts too much attention/empathy5%
We should focus on the present/Move on from the past4%
Table 3. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024
How many Jews died during the Holocaust?I think the Holocaust is exaggerated (yes)I think the Holocaust is exaggerated (no)
Less than one million8%1%
One million to three million26%9%
Three million to five million15%11%
Six million or more16%50%
I don’t know / Prefer not to answer35%29%
Total100%100%
Table 4. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024

Perception of the number of Jews murdered

More than one in three Holocaust skeptics think fewer than three million Jews were murdered during the Holocaust, compared to just one in ten among those who reject Holocaust skepticism (Table 4).

Between 2019 and 2024, there has been a notable increase in the number of Canadians who believe fewer than six million Jews were murdered. This rise is particularly significant among the 18–24 age group (Table 5).

Approximately how many Jews were killed?November 2019May 2024
18–2411%27%
25–3422%31%
35–4423%21%
45–5416%23%
55–6415%21%
65–7416%21%
Total17%24%
Table 5. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024

Holocaust skepticism and negative attitudes towards Jews

There is a clear connection between Holocaust skepticism and negative attitudes toward Jews. Among those aged 18 to 24, one in six believes that Jews exaggerate the Holocaust (Table 6).

Jews exaggerate the HolocaustTotal18–2425–3435–4445–5455–6465+
NET Agree8%16%7%10%7%5%6%
NET Disagree70%56%64%65%64%79%80%
I prefer not to answer22%28%29%25%28%16%14%
Table 6. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024

Social media and Holocaust skepticism

Social media has fundamentally transformed how young people consume information. Among those who believe the Holocaust is exaggerated, 44% say the popularity of an online source affects their level of trust, compared to 26% of those who do not hold this view (Table 7).

Similarly, 37% of Holocaust skeptics say they are more likely to trust viral information, compared to 11% of those who disagree with Holocaust skepticism (Table 8).

Popularity of an online source affects trustYesNo
Agree44%26%
Disagree56%74%
Table 7. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024
Trust in viral informationYesNo
Agree37%11%
Disagree63%89%
Table 8. Source: Leger for the Association for Canadian Studies, September 22–24, 2024

Conclusion

Holocaust skepticism is not due to a lack of available resources but rather an increased reliance on social media for historical information. These findings underscore the need for further analysis of how social media impacts trust in historical facts. Addressing Holocaust skepticism requires strategic engagement with younger audiences and efforts to build critical media literacy to preserve collective memory and combat misinformation.

About the authors

Jack Jedwab

Jack Jedwab is President of the Association for Canadian Studies (ACS) and the Metropolis Institute, which oversees Canada’s largest conference on immigration and integration. He is also the Director of Metropolis Americas, and founder and publisher of Canadian Diversity and Canadian Issues. He holds a Ph.D. in Canadian History from Concordia University, and he has taught at McGill University and the Université du Québec à Montréal. From 1994–1998 he served as Executive Director of the Quebec branch of the Canadian Jewish Congress where he spoke on behalf of the interests of the Jewish community and other identity groups.

Cite this article

Jedwab, J. (2024, Fall/Winter). The rise of Holocaust skepticism and its sources: A Canadian case study. Canadian Issues, 49–52. https://acs-metropolis.ca/en/library/canadian-issues/holocaust-memory-and-learning-canadian-perspectives-on-contemporary-and-future-challenges/the-rise-of-holocaust-skepticism-and-its-sources-a-canadian-case-study

Back to the issue

Stay up to date

Register for our mailing list to get our latest research, publications, event reminders and webinar announcements.