Is negative sentiment toward Americans re-emerging as a feature of Canadian identity and attachment?
For much of the twentieth century, an influential strand of Canadian nationalism defined Canada in opposition to the United States. Protecting a distinct identity meant resisting American cultural and economic influence. George Grant’s Lament for a Nation (1965) warned that continental integration threatened Canadian sovereignty. Seymour Martin Lipset’s Continental Divide (1990) examined enduring differences in the two countries’ values and institutions. Michael Adams’s Fire and Ice (2003) carried this debate into the next century, arguing that Canadian and American values were diverging despite close economic ties.
These works approached Canadian distinctiveness from different perspectives. Their arguments raise a question that bears directly on that which follows: is negative sentiment toward Americans re-emerging as a feature of Canadian identity and attachment? The ACS–EKOS survey of October 15–20, 2026 finds that Canadians attached to their country express less respect and trust toward Americans than those who report little or no attachment. Among the attached, 37% express little or no respect for Americans, compared with 24% of those not attached. Distrust stands at 41% versus 26%. Strongly shared values also draw fewer responses among the attached, at 16% versus 32%.
The findings suggest that attachment to Canada can coexist with greater distance from Americans. This snapshot provides a starting point for tracking whether negative sentiment toward Americans is re-emerging as a feature of Canadian identity and attachment. The open-ended responses help explain the political context: Trump, MAGA and electoral accountability account for 36% of explanations for diminished respect, while leadership, democracy and authoritarianism account for another 20%. The issue is how national attachment intersects with reactions to American politics and perceived treatment of Canada.